Looking for the best pizza in Barnegat, NJ? With so many great options on the menu, choosing the perfect slice at Naples Pizza is part of the experience. Proudly serving the Barnegat community since 1984, we’re known for authentic Italian recipes, fresh ingredients, and a wide variety of pizzas made to satisfy every craving. Our commitment to quality has even earned us recognition as a Community’s Choice winner for Best Pizza in Ocean County.
Whether you’re ordering a classic cheese pie for the family or a loaded specialty pizza for your next get-together, Naples Pizza has something for everyone. Here’s a closer look at our pizza menu and the customer favorites that keep locals coming back.
Classic Pizzas – Timeless Favorites
Cheese Pizza
Our traditional cheese pizza Barnegat style features our signature, slow-simmered tomato sauce topped with a generous blend of premium mozzarella. The crust is baked to golden perfection, offering a satisfying crunch with every bite.
Pepperoni Pizza
A true fan favorite, our pepperoni pie is loaded with perfectly spiced pepperoni slices that crisp up beautifully in the oven. The savory oils blend seamlessly with our melted cheese and rich tomato sauce.
Grandma Pizza
A rustic classic, our Grandma Pizza features a thin, rectangular crust topped with fresh mozzarella, sweet plum marinara sauce, and a sprinkle of fresh basil. It’s a simple yet incredibly flavorful pie that tastes just like nonna used to make.
Specialty Pizzas – Flavor-Packed Creations
If you want to step outside the box and try something unique, explore our specialty pizza Barnegat menu. We carefully craft these pies with premium toppings and unique flavor combinations that thrill the taste buds.
White Pizza
A garlic lover’s dream, our White Pizza skips the tomato sauce. Instead, we spread creamy ricotta, a dash of fresh garlic, and a heavy layer of mozzarella across our daily-made dough.
Meat Lovers Pizza
Designed for the ultimate carnivore, this hearty gourmet pizza Barnegat favorite comes loaded with pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, and bacon. It provides a satisfying, savory punch that will conquer the biggest appetites.
Veggie Lovers Pizza
Packed with fresh peppers, onions, mushrooms, and olives, our Veggie Lovers pie is crisp, colorful, and packed with nutrients. It is the perfect choice for anyone seeking a lighter, farm-fresh flavor profile.
BBQ Chicken Pizza
We swap traditional marinara for a tangy, sweet barbecue sauce, then top it with tender chicken pieces and melted cheese. It is easy to see why this is considered one of the best specialty pies Ocean County has to offer.
Gluten-Free Pizza
For our gluten-sensitive guests, we offer a delicious 12-inch personal pizza with a gluten-free crust. Customize it with your favorite toppings and enjoy a pie that meets your dietary needs without sacrificing flavor.
Build-Your-Own Pizza Options
Everyone has their own specific cravings. That is why we offer an extensive custom pizza Barnegat menu. You have complete control over your meal, allowing you to customize your pie to your exact dietary preferences or wild flavor experiments.
Step-by-Step Customization
When you create your own pizza NJ style at Naples, you lead the entire process. Start by choosing your ideal crust size. Next, pick between our classic tomato sauce, garlic oil, or a white ricotta base. Finally, pile on your favorite cheeses and fresh toppings pizza Ocean County locals rave about having this control over their pizzas.
Popular Customer Combinations
Many guests love combining sweet and spicy flavors, like pairing pineapple with jalapeños. Others prefer classic Italian combinations like sausage, sweet peppers, and extra mozzarella. Whether you need a vegetarian masterpiece or a meat-heavy feast, our flexible options make it happen.
Pizza Sizes & Family Favorites
We know that pizza nights look different for everyone. Whether you are grabbing a quick lunch for yourself or feeding an entire soccer team, our menu adapts to your needs.
Personal, Medium, and Large Pies
Our sizes range from personal pies for a quick solo meal to the classic large pizza Barnegat families rely on for dinner. A large pie provides plenty of generous slices to share around the table.
Family Gatherings and Parties
Hosting a party? We offer fantastic family pizza deals Ocean County residents use to feed a crowd without breaking the bank. Pairing a few large pies with our famous garlic knots and salads creates a complete, stress-free feast.
Takeout and Pickup
We make takeout pizza Barnegat orders incredibly easy. Simply give us a call or place your order online, and we will have your piping-hot meal ready for pickup exactly when you need it.
Fresh Ingredients That Make the Difference
You cannot bake award-winning pies without exceptional components. The secret to our 2023 Ocean County Community’s Choice Award for Best Pizza lies in our unwavering commitment to quality.
Daily-Made Dough
Great pizza starts from the bottom up. We prepare our homemade pizza dough NJ-style every single morning. It’s mixed and balled, then proofed in the fridge for 24-48 hours to develop the perfect flavor. A couple of hours before service, we let the dough reach room temperature. It’s then stretched to ensure a fresh, airy crust with the perfect amount of chew in every bite.
Premium Cheeses and Toppings
We source only the best fresh pizza ingredients Barnegat has to offer. From a pound of premium mozzarella that melts flawlessly to crisp vegetables chopped fresh daily, every topping is selected for maximum flavor.
Traditional Sauces
Our tomato sauce is a closely guarded family secret. Our pies are topped with about eight ounces of our family-recipe sauce. This process ensures a consistent, rich flavor that we’ve been serving to Barnegat families for 40 years.
Staff & Customer Picks – What to Try First
Not sure where to start? We highly recommend one of our famous Grandma Pies. These square, thin-crust masterpieces perfectly capture our authentic roots and are a customer favorite. Try the traditional Grandma Pie, layered with fresh mozzarella, crushed tomatoes, garlic, and basil, or the Veggie Grandma.
Another staff favorite is the Naples Special. This loaded pan pizza brings together a little bit of everything (pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, and peppers) giving you a massive burst of flavor in every single bite.
Our Pizza Menu in Barnegat: Best Picks for Every Craving
Are you ready to taste the Barnegat area’s most celebrated pies? Browse our full menu online and find the perfect meal for your cravings. Whether you dine in our cozy dining room at 550 N Main Street or grab a quick takeout order, we promise a meal you will not forget.
Place your order online today and discover exactly why the community voted Naples Pizza as their favorite spot for award-winning Italian food!
