Searching for award-winning pizza in Barnegat? Look no further than Naples Pizza & Restaurant. Proud Winner of the 2023 Ocean County Community’s Choice Award for Pizza, we’ve been serving authentic Italian cuisine since 1984, bringing families together and keeping customers coming back week after week. From our signature pizza-making process to our commitment to the local community, here’s what makes Naples Pizza special.
Our History: Four Decades of Authentic Italian Tradition
Andrea Esposito opened Naples Pizza & Restaurant at 550 N Main St in 1984 with a simple mission: to bring authentic Italian cooking to Barnegat. What started as a neighborhood pizzeria has evolved into a beloved gathering place where generations of families create memories over hot slices and homestyle Italian meals.
Andrea’s passion for cooking and dedication to customer satisfaction show in every dish. His success with Naples led him to open Villa Amalfi in Toms River and Fusaro Pizzeria in Manahawkin, but Naples remains the heart of his family business; a place where tradition meets excellence.
Art of the Crust: How We Make Our Pizza
Great pizza starts with great dough. Our process begins 24 to 48 hours before your first bite.
Each morning, we mix and shape fresh dough balls that rest in the refrigerator for one to two days. This proofing period develops the flavor and texture that makes our crust stand out. Before service, we bring the dough to room temperature for an hour or two—an essential step that makes stretching easier and creates that perfect, airy texture.
When you order, we hand-stretch each dough ball in a flour bowl to your desired size. Then comes eight ounces of our signature sauce and a full pound of premium cheese. The pizza goes into our 550-degree oven for exactly 10 minutes, emerging with a crispy, golden crust and perfectly melted cheese.
This attention to detail transforms simple ingredients into something extraordinary.
Quality Ingredients: Fresh, Local, and Authentic
At Naples Pizza & Restaurant, we believe great food begins with great ingredients. That’s why we source locally whenever possible.
During summer months, we use produce from our own garden and local vendors. Our tomatoes come from both Italian and California growers, carefully selected for their sweetness and acidity. We use premium Wisconsin cheese delivered fresh by local suppliers who share our commitment to quality.
Perhaps most importantly, our sauces follow traditional family recipes passed down through generations. These time-tested formulas create the rich, balanced flavors that make our pizza taste like home.
Diverse Menu Options: Something for Everyone
While we’re known as a Barnegat pizza restaurant, our menu offers much more. Classic pies range from simple cheese to specialty combinations loaded with fresh toppings. We also serve hearty Italian entrées like pasta, chicken dishes, and seafood; all prepared with the same care as our pizza.
We understand dietary needs vary. That’s why we offer personal gluten-free pizzas so everyone can enjoy a hot slice at Naples. Bring your favorite beverage (we’re BYOB) and settle in for a meal that satisfies.
Community: Serving Barnegat with Pride
Naples Pizza & Restaurant is more than just a place to grab a bite—it’s an award-winning staple of the Barnegat community. For years, we’ve worked hard to serve delicious food and provide a welcoming atmosphere, and the support we’ve received from our neighbors has been truly humbling. As a community-voted favorite and proud winner of the Ocean County pizza awards, we’re honored to be recognized by the people who matter most—our customers. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick slice, a family dinner, or to celebrate a special occasion, we’re here to make every visit memorable. Thank you for allowing us to be a part of your lives for decades, and we look forward to serving you for many more to come!
Authentic Italian Pizza & Fresh Ingredients in Barnegat
For over 40 years, Naples Pizza & Restaurant has earned its reputation as the top-rated Barnegat pizza restaurant. Our commitment to quality ingredients, authentic recipes, and exceptional service keeps families returning generation after generation, and it’s why we were named the 2023 Ocean County Community’s Choice Award Winner for Pizza.
Ready to taste the difference? Order online today or visit us at 550 N Main St. Experience why locals call us the best pizza in Barnegat! We think you’ll agree!
