Looking for the best takeout pizza near Toms River, NJ? While Toms River offers many pizza options, more residents are making the short drive to Barnegat for award-winning takeout from Naples Pizza. Voted the 2023 Ocean County Community’s Choice Award Winner for Pizza, Naples Pizza is known for authentic Italian family recipes, fresh high-quality ingredients, and a fast, convenient pickup experience. Just minutes down Route 9, Naples Pizza has become a top choice for Toms River families who want consistently great pizza worth the drive.
Here’s why more Toms River customers are making the quick trip to Barnegat for fresh, authentic Italian takeout from Naples Pizza.
Location That Makes the Drive Easy
Naples Pizza sits at 550 N Main St, Suite D in Barnegat—right off Route 9. For Toms River commuters already traveling south, it’s a natural stop on the way home. Pull off, grab your order, and you’re back on the road in minutes.
Ample parking, a streamlined pickup process, and a staff that has your order ready when you arrive make the whole experience refreshingly simple. There’s no circling the block, no waiting around. Just hot food, ready to go.
Four Decades of Authentic Italian Cooking
Naples Pizza has been serving Ocean County since 1984. Owner Andrea Esposito built the restaurant on traditional family recipes and a genuine passion for Italian cooking—and that foundation hasn’t changed.
The dough is made fresh every day. The sauce blends premium Italian and California tomatoes, seasoned to a recipe that has stood the test of time. Every pie is topped with high-quality Wisconsin cheese sourced from local vendors. These aren’t shortcuts or substitutes. They’re the ingredients that make a real difference in the final product.
Generations of families have grown up eating at Naples. That kind of loyalty doesn’t happen by accident.
Menu Highlights Worth the Drive
The menu at Naples Pizza covers a wide range, but a few items consistently stand out for takeout orders.
Grandma Pizza
The Grandma Pizza is a thin, square pie topped with plum marinara, mozzarella, and fresh basil. It has a distinct, nostalgic quality that’s hard to find elsewhere in Ocean County. Locals rave about it, and for good reason! It’s the kind of pizza that reminds you why homemade still wins.
New York-Style Thin Crust
The classic cheese pizza features Naples’ signature tomato sauce and a generous layer of mozzarella on a hand-stretched, freshly made crust. Crispy on the outside, soft in the middle. It’s the standard by which other pies get measured.
Specialty Pies
Our full menu includes Meat Lovers, White Garlic, Buffalo Chicken, Broccoli Rabe Sausage, Veggie, and many more. There’s also a Build Your Own option for anyone who knows exactly what they want.
Gluten-Free Options
Naples offers personal gluten-free pizzas, so dietary restrictions don’t have to mean missing out.
Beyond pizza, our menu features homemade pasta dishes, calzones, strombolis, hot and cold subs, wraps, and fresh salads. The Antipasto Salad is a particular favorite among regulars. Whatever your group is craving, there’s something on the menu to satisfy it.
Ordering Online Is Quick and Straightforward
Naples Pizza uses the HungerRush platform for online orders, making the process fast and hassle-free. Browse the full menu, customize your order, choose pickup, and pay—all before you leave the house or office.
By the time you arrive at 550 N Main St, your food is hot and ready. No waiting, no surprises. It’s the kind of seamless experience that turns a first-time visitor into a regular.
You can place an order online or call (609) 698-3830.
What Customers Are Saying
The reviews speak for themselves:
- “Best pizza in town! All of the workers are so nice and helpful. They are consistently great with food quality and customer service. 10/10.” — Sherbertski
- “The best pizza in Barnegat. Always fresh and tasty! I won’t go anywhere else for an antipasto salad or pizzas!!!” — Brianna P.
- “Always good. My family always did takeout until one recent trip. Very good and attentive service.” — Suzanne C.
With a 4.49 average rating, Naples Pizza has earned its reputation across Ocean County.
Take Out Pizza Near Tom’s River
The short drive from Toms River to Naples Pizza in Barnegat is absolutely worth it. With fresh, hand-tossed dough, house-made sauce, premium ingredients, and over 40 years of perfected family recipes, Naples Pizza delivers a takeout experience that’s hard to beat in Ocean County. It’s no wonder we won the 2023 Ocean County Community’s Choice Award for Best Pizza!
Ready to taste the difference? Order online at barnegatpizza.com, call us at (609) 698-3830, or visit us at 550 N Main St, Suite D, Barnegat. We’ll have your order hot and ready when you arrive!
