Quick answer: Naples Pizza in Barnegat, NJ is the top choice for pizza near Long Beach Island. Located just off Route 72, Naples Pizza has served Ocean County families since 1984 with authentic Italian recipes, specialty pies, pasta, salads, and easy takeout, making it a natural stop between the beach and home.
Whether you’ve spent the day on the beaches of Long Beach Island, boating on Barnegat Bay, or exploring the Jersey Shore, a hot pizza is the perfect way to end the day. A long day at the beach has a way of working up a serious appetite. Sun, salt air, and hours of swimming or fishing will do that. By the time you’re rinsed off and ready to head out, the last thing most families want to do is cook. That’s when pizza becomes the obvious answer, and if you’re looking for pizza near Long Beach Island, Naples Pizza in Barnegat delivers the real thing.
Serving Ocean County since 1984, Naples Pizza is a short drive from the LBI bridge via Route 72, making it one of the most convenient dinner stops for beachgoers heading home or back to their rental. From the best pies for big beach appetites to why takeout makes the whole trip easier, here’s why Naples Pizza is a must-visit on your next trip to LBI.
Why Is Pizza the Perfect Meal After a Beach Day?
BBQ Chicken Pizza: Smoky and flavorful with tender BBQ chicken and melted cheese
There’s a reason pizza is the unofficial dinner of every shore vacation. A few of them, actually.
First, it feeds everyone. Kids, picky eaters, people who want meat, people who don’t—pizza covers it all without anyone going home hungry. Second, there’s no cooking and no cleanup. After hours outdoors, that matters more than you’d think. Third, it travels. Whether you’re eating at your rental, heading home, or sitting at a picnic table, a pizza box is about as portable as dinner gets.
Pizza also scales easily for groups. One pie for two people or six pies for a crowd—it works either way. On a warm summer evening, there’s something genuinely satisfying about sitting down to a hot, cheesy slice after a full day by the water.
Is Naples Pizza Conveniently Located Near Long Beach Island?
Naples Pizza is located at 550 N Main St, Suite D, in Barnegat, NJ, just off Route 72, the main road connecting Long Beach Island to the mainland. For anyone crossing the Manahawkin Bridge and heading north, or anyone coming in from the Barnegat Bay side, Naples Pizza sits right along a natural route home.
It’s a logical stop. No major detour, no backtracking. Just pull in, pick up your order, and keep moving. For families with tired kids or a long drive ahead, that kind of convenience makes a real difference.
What Are the Best Pizzas for Big Beach Appetites?
Whole Grandma Pizzas
Naples Pizza’s menu covers the full range, from crowd-pleasing classics to specialty pies worth ordering by name.
Cheese Pizza — The foundation. Crispy thin crust, balanced tomato sauce, and quality mozzarella. Simple, consistent, and always a hit with kids.
Grandma Pizza — One of the most popular pies on the menu. Baked in a rectangular pan, the Grandma Pizza features a thin square crust, plum tomato sauce, fresh basil, and melted mozzarella. The edges crisp up beautifully, and the square slices make it easy to share. As one longtime customer put it: “The Grandma’s Pie is one of our favorites—the mozzarella has great flavor, the sauce is delicious, and the crust has the perfect thin, crispy crunch every time.”
BBQ Chicken — A summer staple. Smoky, slightly sweet, and satisfying after a hot day outside.
Veggie — Fresh toppings keep this one feeling light, which makes it a natural fit after hours in the sun.
Meat Lovers — For the bigger appetites in the group. Loaded and filling in all the right ways.
Half Plain Half Special — Practically built for families with different preferences. No negotiation required.
What Else Is on the Menu Beyond Pizza?
Chicken Parmigiana with Spaghetti
Not everyone wants pizza, and Naples Pizza handles that too.
Our full menu includes Italian food like Chicken Parm, Eggplant Parm, and pasta dishes like penne vodka, which customers consistently call a standout. Salads round out the options for anyone wanting something lighter after a day in the heat. Appetizers fill in the gaps for groups that want to snack while the main order is being decided.
For larger groups with varied tastes, this variety means everyone finds something. No second stop required.
How Does Takeout from Naples Pizza Make the Trip Home Easier?
Ordering ahead is the move. Call in or order online, then time your pickup to land right around when you’re leaving the island. The food comes out fresh, and you’re back on the road without a long wait.
From there, the options are flexible. Eat at your beach rental. Find a spot at a picnic table. Pull over somewhere scenic and eat before the drive back. Or bring it home and enjoy it without anyone having to cook. Naples Pizza’s takeout travels well, especially the Grandma Pizza, which holds its texture even on the ride home.
What Activities Near Long Beach Island Pair Well with a Post-Beach Pizza Stop?
Naples Pizza works as a dinner stop after just about anything the LBI area has to offer:
-
- Beach days on Long Beach Island’s Atlantic-facing shores
- Boating and fishing on Barnegat Bay
- Paddleboarding in the calmer bay waters
- Mini golf nights in Manahawkin or Barnegat
- Sunset watching from the bay side
- Summer baseball games at local fields
- Camping at Stafford Township area campgrounds
- Family vacations based out of LBI or surrounding towns
Long days outdoors end the same way: everyone’s hungry, nobody wants to cook, and pizza fixes both problems at once.
Why Do Families Choose Naples Pizza Near Barnegat Bay?
Naples Pizza has been a fixture in Ocean County since 1984. Owner Andrea Esposito built the restaurant on authentic Italian family recipes, and that foundation hasn’t changed in over 40 years. The result is the kind of consistency that’s hard to fake, and that customers notice immediately.
In 2023, Naples Pizza was named the Community’s Choice Winner for Best Pizza in Ocean County, a recognition voted on entirely by local residents. The restaurant holds a 4.49-star rating across more than 322 reviews, and the feedback tells a consistent story: quality ingredients, friendly service, and food that feels like it was made with care.
“Best pizza in the area. Been coming here for about 40 years. Always exceptional.” — CJ Caufield, Google Review
That kind of loyalty doesn’t come from gimmicks. It comes from doing the same things right, year after year.
End the Day Right at Naples Pizza
Shore days leave an impression. The smell of the ocean, the sound of the waves, kids exhausted in the backseat—those memories stick. The right dinner at the end of that day becomes part of it.
Naples Pizza has been that dinner for Ocean County families for more than four decades. Fresh ingredients, authentic recipes, and a location that makes sense for anyone coming off Long Beach Island. It’s the kind of place that earns a spot in the rotation fast.
Order takeout online or call ahead at (609) 698-3830. Find Naples Pizza at 550 N Main St, Suite D, Barnegat, NJ 08005, right off Route 72 on your way home from the island.
