Are you looking for a delicious specialty pizza Barnegat residents rave about? Finding a pie that satisfies everyone at the table can sometimes be a challenge. At Naples Pizza, we solve that problem with a massive menu designed for every type of craving. From rich, meat-loaded pies to fresh, vegetable-packed options, we offer a wide variety of pizzas made with authentic recipes and fresh ingredients.
Whether you live right here in town or are searching for gourmet pizza near Toms River, our kitchen delivers bold flavors that keep customers coming back. We proudly serve families across the area, offering quality meals that make dinnertime easy and enjoyable.
Here’s a closer look at our best specialty pies, helping you discover your new favorite unique pizza Ocean County has to offer.
Classic Favorites with a Twist
Sometimes, a traditional pie is exactly what you need. These may be classics, but our quality ingredients make them stand out from the crowd. We start with fresh dough made daily, topped with our signature pizza sauce and premium mozzarella.
You can keep things simple with our traditional Cheese Pizza, or upgrade to an Extra Cheese Pizza for a richer experience. If you prefer a lighter, fresher taste, our Margherita pizza features fresh basil, mozzarella, and a bright tomato sauce that honors authentic Italian cooking traditions.
Meat Lover’s Specialty Pizzas
If you want a hearty, filling meal, our protein-packed pies are guaranteed to hit the spot. These bold creations are loaded with premium meats and rich cheeses.
The classic Meat Lovers Pizza comes packed with meatballs, pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon. For an even bigger meal, try the Naples Special, which combines mushrooms, onions, pepperoni, sausage, and peppers. If you love a thick, hearty slice, our Stuffed Pizza is packed with meatballs, pepperoni, sausage, ham, and creamy ricotta. We also offer savory steak options like the Steak Pizza Pep Onion and the comforting Cheesesteak Pizza, featuring a satisfying mix of steak and yellow American cheese.
Chicken Specialty Pizzas
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza: Crispy fried chicken, bacon, cheddar, and ranch with cheese and pizza sauce.
Chicken pizzas offer incredible flavor variety, ranging from smoky and spicy to rich and creamy. They are among our most popular items for a good reason.
If you like a little heat, the Buffalo Chicken Pizza pairs spicy buffalo sauce with melted cheese. For a sweeter, smoky profile, the BBQ Chicken Pizza is always a crowd-pleaser. The Chicken Bacon Ranch combines crispy fried chicken, bacon, cheddar, and ranch dressing for a decadent treat. We also serve up Italian-inspired favorites like the Chicken Parm Pizza, the CHX Italiano, and the flavorful CHX Marsala.
White & Ricotta-Based Pizzas
White Garlic Pizza: A creamy, garlicky option with ricotta and cheese.
If you are craving a white pizza Barnegat locals love, we have several creamy, rich, and no-red-sauce options. These pies rely on garlic, ricotta, and premium mozzarella to deliver massive flavor.
Our White Garlic Pizza is a creamy, garlicky option perfect for any occasion. The White Veggie pie takes that same rich base and adds onions, mushrooms, peppers, spinach, broccoli, and tomatoes. For a savory, traditional Italian combination, try the Broccoli Rabe Sausage pizza. We also feature a decadent Alfredo Pizza topped with a rich cheese sauce.
Fresh & Veggie Specialty Pizzas
Vegetable lovers have plenty of fresh, lighter, and ingredient-forward options at Naples Pizza. A great veggie pizza Barnegat style means crisp vegetables and perfectly balanced flavors.
Our classic Veggie Pizza features onions, mushrooms, peppers, spinach, broccoli, and garlic. We also offer a Chopped Veggie pie for a different texture. If you want a truly refreshing slice, explore our Bruschetta Pizza, Salad Pizza, or the unique Cesar Salad ZZA. The Tomatoes Garlic Pizza keeps things simple with fresh tomatoes, garlic, and plum marinara.
Unique & Signature Specialty Pizzas
1/2 BBQ Chicken Pizza & 1/2 Hawaiian Pizza
Adventurous eaters will find plenty to love on our menu. If you are looking for a unique pizza Ocean County style, we have creative combinations you won’t find anywhere else.
Seafood fans can indulge in our Shrimp Scampi Pizza or the classic Anchovies Pizza. The Hawaiian Pizza provides that famous sweet-and-savory mix of ham and pineapple. For something completely different, try the RANDAZZZOOOO or our thick, airy Focaccia pie. Can’t decide? Order a Half Plain Half Special to get the best of both worlds.
Grandma-Style & Square Pizzas
Grandma Pizza: A square pizza topped with plum marinara, basil, and cheese.
Our square pies feature a crispy crust and bold sauces, honoring old-school baking techniques. A great Grandma pizza Barnegat style is thin, crispy, and packed with flavor.
The traditional Grandma Pizza features plum marinara, fresh basil, and premium cheese. We also offer a Grandma Veggie loaded with fresh vegetables. If you love rich, creamy sauces, the Grandma-Vodka pie and the Vodka Margy bring a delicious vodka sauce twist to these crispy square favorites.
Pasta-Inspired Specialty Pizzas
Penne Vodka: Penne pasta pizza with creamy vodka sauce.
Why choose between Italian comfort food and pizza when you can have both? Our pasta-inspired pies are a massive hit for anyone craving a heavy, satisfying meal.
The Baked Ziti Pizza takes hearty ziti pasta and bakes it right onto the crust with delicious pizza toppings. The Penne Vodka Pizza combines tender penne pasta with our creamy vodka sauce, creating a uniquely delicious slice.
Gluten-Free & Custom Options
We believe everyone should be able to enjoy a great pizza night. That is why we prioritize accessibility and dietary needs with our Gluten-Free Pizza. You get a crispy gluten-free crust topped with our signature cheese and pizza sauce, ensuring you do not miss out on the Naples Pizza experience.
What’s the Best Specialty Pizza to Try First?
BBQ Chicken Pizza: Smoky and flavorful with tender BBQ chicken and melted cheese.
If you are wondering, “What pizza should I order?” or searching for the “best specialty pizza near me,” here are our top recommendations.
Our most popular picks are the Meat Lovers and the BBQ Chicken Pizza, which fly out the door every single weekend. A major staff favorite is the Grandma-Vodka pie, thanks to its perfectly crispy crust and rich sauce. If you are a first-time customer, we highly recommend the Naples Special to experience a little bit of everything that makes our ingredients great.
Why Naples Pizza Is a Top Choice for Specialty Pizza in Barnegat
We were proudly Voted 2023 Ocean County Community’s Choice Award Winner – Pizza Category. This honor reflects our 40-year commitment to serving the community.
Customers keep coming back because of our fresh ingredients, incredible menu variety, and unwavering consistency. We have built a strong local reputation by treating every customer like family. Whether you are looking for a specialty pizza Barnegat families trust or gourmet pizza near Toms River, Naples Pizza delivers quality every time.
Specialty Pizza in Barnegat | Naples Pizza Favorites
Ready to try the best pizza in town? Our takeout process is fast and easy, ensuring your food arrives home hot and fresh. Even if you live in nearby towns like Toms River or Manahawkin, our bold flavors and massive menu make the trip completely worth the drive. Place your order online or call us today to discover your new favorite slice.
